Like a good man, a good black eyeliner is hard to find. As you might expect, I've tried many, but most of them end up traveling into the corners of my eyes, and down into that undereye area (making my dark circles look even worse, thank you very much!).

I've tried cheap ones, expensive ones, and some in the middle, and the best is definitely Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner in Onyx. It's waterproof, but you don't have to scratch your eyes out to get it off at night.

I first discovered this little gem quite a few years ago, when it was still called Great Wear. I used it the night of my senior prom. We stayed out all night, took a nap, and when I woke up I was surprised to see that I did NOT look like a raccoon!

Unstoppable Eyeliner is about $7 and is available in any drugstore.